June 8th, 2010

Continental European Legislative and Judicial Trends: Draft Bill on the Amendment of the Spanish Accounts Audit Act: Potential Impact on Professional Indemnity Policies

Posted at 1:00 AM ET

GC Editor

2010_legislative_thumb-2David Lewin, Managing Director
Contact

In the September 2009 issue in this series, Recent Legislative and Judicial Developments in Continental Europe Affecting the Casualty Insurance Industry, we referred briefly to the ongoing discussions around the controversial topic of auditors’ liability.

Following publication of the draft bill on November 13, 2009, this is a good time to
provide more detailed insight.

Under Section 1.1 of the current Accounts Audit Act (Law 19/1988 of July 12, AAA),
as amended, the main purpose of an audit is the issuance of a report on a company’s
accounts that may produce effects relating to third parties. The audit of the annual accounts attests that the accounts provide a fair view of the company’s business, financial position, results, and resources obtained and applied during the period reviewed. The auditor is required to affirm that the report of management agrees with the accounts reviewed (Section 1.2, AAA).

Section 11.1 of AAA provides that auditors are liable for any damage arising out of the breach of their obligations in accordance with the general civil law rules. In essence, this means that the auditor can be liable in contract and in tort to the client (the audited company) and/or third parties. In principle, that liability is based on fault and is unlimited to the extent that the auditor will respond with all his/her current and future assets pursuant to the general rule set forth in Section 1.911 of the Civil Code. Section 11.2 of AAA adds that whenever the audit is carried out by an auditor working in or for an audit firm, both the auditor and the firm shall be jointly and severally liable.

Both the auditors and their firms are required to set up various forms of security to enable them to respond to all damages they may cause in the performance of their activities. Security shall be provided in several forms, one of which is professional indemnity insurance. The limits of cover are fixed, with an initial base amount (currently EUR300,506), subject to increase depending on annual revenues. For audit firms the base amount will be multiplied by the number of partners at the firm.

Circumstances have not been positive for auditors in recent years in Spain. There is a general perception that auditors are “guarantors” of the financial health of companies, or, as one Justice of the Supreme Court described it, “notaries.” Case law has highlighted the public interest of audit reports and extended the duty of care of auditors not only to the audited company itself and the shareholders, but to third parties that may maintain relations with the company. Consequently, third parties may also rely on the audit report.

The Supreme Court has pursued a variety of theories to assert causation between the auditor’s actions and a harmful result. It has applied the doctrine of improper joint and several liability. (1) According to this doctrine created by case law, liability can be imposed on a joint and several basis where it is impossible to discern or individualize the conduct of the people involved in the event giving rise to damage. The so called “PSV case” is representative of this approach. The claimants in this case were 450 individual members of a building cooperative association. They sued the association’s auditor, the audit firm and the audit firm’s insurance company. They did not sue the managers and administrators of both the cooperative and their management company who were directly culpable for the financial disaster that ended in the bankruptcy of the cooperative. The manager was found guilty of several criminal charges and convicted. All efforts of the defendants to join the other potential defendants to the proceedings were useless. The Supreme Court on October 14, 2008 ruled against the auditor, the audit firm and their insurer. They were ordered to indemnify jointly and severally for all damages claimed, without any limitations on the extent to which the auditor or the audit firm contributed to the causation of the damages suffered by the claimants.

The proposed reform of the AAA is based on the Directive 2006/43/EC of the European Parliament and the Council of May 17, 2006 and the Commission Recommendation of June 5, 2008, concerning the limitation of the civil liability of statutory auditors and audit firms.

The most significant proposed change includes the introduction of a new Paragraph 2 and the amendment of current Paragraph 2 which is numbered 3, in Section 11 of the AAA.

The liability of an auditor or of the audit firm shall be enforceable on a personal and individualized basis, excluding any damage caused by the audited company or the third party. Joint and several liability may be asserted only where the cause of the damage cannot be individualized or the degree of contribution to the harmful result of the agents involved cannot be established precisely.

The proposed amendment to current Paragraph 2, future Paragraph 3, provides that both the auditor and his/her firm will be jointly and severally liable for the audit report issued on behalf of the audit firm, but “within the limits indicated in the preceding paragraph” (our emphasis). This means that they will be jointly and severally liable for their share or quota of liability that has been individually identified and allocated.   

The proposed reform also seeks to reduce the limitation term of contractual actions against auditors from the current 15-year term to four years. This term would begin on the date of the audit report.

It would seem that the Spanish legislator has followed the method outlined in Section 5 of the Commission Recommendation. This establishes a set of principles by virtue of which a statutory auditor or an audit firm is not liable beyond its actual contribution to the loss suffered by a claimant and is, accordingly, not jointly and severally liable with other wrongdoers.

From an insurance perspective, it would be reasonable to assume that auditor professional indemnity cover requirements and, therefore, premiums, will be reduced.

However, the question arises as to whether the proposed legislation effectively limits the auditor’s liability. The fact that joint and several liability may be asserted where the cause of the damage cannot be individualized or liability cannot be allocated among the various wrongdoers, paves the way to imposing joint and several liability. In practice it may be very difficult to ascertain who is to be blamed and in what percentages for the damage. From this perspective, the auditor’s legal position may not have improved, and may have worsened to some extent. The doctrine of improper joint and several liability created by recent case law has been codified as law.

In conclusion, the resulting limitation of liability should logically lead to the reduction of insurance cover requirements, but it remains to be seen how the proposed new rules, if they are finally approved in the current terms, will be construed by courts.

Note:  

1 Decisions of October 9 and 14, 2008 (RJ 2008\6042 and RJ 2008\6931); March 5, 2009 (RJ 2009\1631); and May 27, 2009 (JUR 2009\279232).

Download the full report >>

View the Fall 2009 report >>

Click here to have the rest of this series — and other GC Capital Ideas updates — delivered to your inbox. 

Securities or investments, as applicable, are offered in the United States through GC Securities, a division of MMC Securities Corp., a US registered broker-dealer and member FINRA/SIPC. Main Office: 1166 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10036. Phone: (212) 345-5000. Securities or investments, as applicable, are offered in the European Union by GC Securities, a division of MMC Securities (Europe) Ltd., which is authorized and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. Reinsurance products are placed through qualified affiliates of Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC. MMC Securities Corp., MMC Securities (Europe) Ltd. and Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC are affiliates owned by Marsh & McLennan Companies. This communication is not intended as an offer to sell or a solicitation of any offer to buy any security, financial instrument, reinsurance or insurance product.

 

Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC provides this report for general information only. The information contained herein is based on sources we believe reliable, but we do not guarantee its accuracy, and it should be understood to be general insurance/reinsurance information only. Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC makes no representations or warranties, express or implied. The information is not intended to be taken as advice with respect to any individual situation and cannot be relied upon as such.

 

Readers are cautioned not to place undue reliance on any historical, current or forward-looking statements. Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC undertakes no obligation to update or revise publicly any historical, current or forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, research, future events or otherwise.

 

Statements concerning, tax, accounting, legal or regulatory matters should be understood to be general observations based solely on our experience as reinsurance brokers and risk consultants, and may not be relied upon as tax, accounting, legal or regulatory advice which we are not authorized to provide. All such matters should be reviewed with your own qualified advisors in these areas.

 

Category: Casualty

Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC Terms and Conditions of Use

PLEASE READ THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SERVICE (“TERMS”) BEFORE USING THIS SITE.

By continuing to access or use this site, or any service on this site, you signify your acceptance of the TERMS. From time to time, Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC (“Guy Carpenter”) may modify the TERMS. Accordingly, please continue to review the TERMS whenever accessing or using this site. Your use of this site, or any service on the site, after the posting of modifications to the TERMS will constitute your acceptance of the TERMS, as modified. If, at any time, you do not wish to accept the TERMS, you may not use the site. Any terms or conditions proposed by you that are in addition to or which conflict with the TERMS are expressly rejected by Guy Carpenter and shall be of no force or effect.

1. User Assent to Terms and Conditions of Service

You represent that you have read and agree to be bound by the TERMS for GCCapitalIdeas.com. You further agree: (i) to comply with U.S. law regarding the transmission of any data obtained from the Service (as defined herein) in accordance with the TERMS; (ii) not to use the Service for illegal purposes; and (iii) not to interfere or disrupt networks connected to the Service.

2. Disclaimer

All content provided on this Web site is based upon information which we believe to be reliable and should be understood to be general insurance information only. It is not intended to be taken as advice with respect to any individual situation and cannot be relied upon as such. Consult your reinsurance/insurance advisors with respect to individual coverage issues.

Guy Carpenter makes no representations or warranties, express or implied, with respect to the accuracy or reliability of the content contained on this Web site. Readers are cautioned not to place undue reliance on any historical, current or forward-looking statements. Guy Carpenter undertakes no obligation to update or revise publicly any historical, current or forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, research, future events or otherwise.

Statements concerning, tax, accounting, legal or regulatory matters should be understood to be general observations based solely on our experience as reinsurance brokers and risk consultants, and may not be relied upon as tax, accounting, legal or regulatory advice which we are not authorized to provide. All such matters should be reviewed with your own qualified advisors in these areas.

3. Intellectual Property

This Web site, including, but not limited to, text, content, photographs, video, audio, and graphics (the “Service”), is protected by copyrights, trademarks, service marks, international treaties and/or other proprietary rights and laws of the U.S. and other countries. The Service is also protected as a collective work or compilation under U.S. copyright and other laws and treaties. All individual articles, columns and other elements making up the Service are also copyrighted works. You agree to abide by all applicable copyright and other laws, as well as any additional copyright notices or restrictions contained in the Service.

4. Restrictions on Use

You may not use the Service for any illegal purpose or in any manner inconsistent with the TERMS. You agree to use the Service solely for the use and benefit of your own organization, and not for resale or other transfer to, or use by or for the benefit of, any other person or entity. You agree not to use, transfer, distribute or dispose of any information contained in the Service in any manner that could compete with the business of Guy Carpenter. You acknowledge that the Service has been developed, compiled, prepared, revised, selected and arranged by Guy Carpenter and others (including certain other information sources) through the application of methods and standards of judgment developed and applied through the expenditure of substantial time, effort and money and constitutes valuable intellectual property and trade secrets of Guy Carpenter and such others. You agree to protect the proprietary rights of Guy Carpenter and all others having rights in the Service during and after the term of this agreement and to comply with all reasonable written requests made by Guy Carpenter or its suppliers of content, equipment or otherwise (“Suppliers”) to protect their and others’ contractual, statutory and common law rights in the Service. You agree to notify Guy Carpenter in writing promptly upon becoming aware of any unauthorized access or use of the Service by any party or of any claim that the Service infringes upon any copyright, trademark or other contractual, statutory or common law rights.

5. Further Restrictions on Use

You may not copy, reproduce, recompile, decompile, disassemble, reverse engineer, distribute, publish, display, perform, modify, upload to, create derivative works from, transmit or in any way exploit any part of the Service, except that you may download material from the Service and/or make print copies for use within your organization, provided that all copies retain all copyright and other proprietary notices. The analysis and presentation included in the Service may not be recirculated, redistributed or published by you without Guy Carpenter’s prior written consent. Modification of the Service’s content would be a violation of Guy Carpenter’s copyright and other proprietary rights. Additionally, you may not offer any part of the Service for sale or distribute it over any other medium including but not limited to over-the-air television or radio broadcast, a computer network or hyperlink framing on the internet without the prior written consent of Guy Carpenter. The Service and the information contained therein may not be used to construct a database of any kind. Nor may the Service be stored (in its entirety or in any part) in databases for access by you or any third party or to distribute any database services containing all or part of the Service. You may not use the Service in any way to improve the quality of any data sold or contributed by you to any third party. Furthermore, you may not use any of Guy Carpenter’s names or marks in any manner that creates the impression such names or marks belong to or are associated with you or imply any endorsement by Guy Carpenter, and you acknowledge that you have no ownership rights in and to any of these names or marks. You will not use the Service, the information contained therein or any of Guy Carpenter’s names or marks in unsolicited mailings or spam material and will not spam or send unsolicited mailings to any person or entity using the Service.

6. License

You acquire no rights or licenses in or to the Service and materials contained therein other than the limited right to utilize the Service in accordance with the TERMS.

7. Rights Reserved

All present and future rights in and to trade secrets, patents, copyrights, trade names, trademarks, service marks, databases, know-how and other proprietary rights of any type under the laws of any governmental authority, domestic or foreign, including rights in and to all applications and registrations relating to the Service (the “IP Rights”) shall, as between you and Guy Carpenter, at all times be and remain the sole and exclusive property of Guy Carpenter. All present and future rights in and title to the Service (including the right to exploit the Service and any portions of the Service over any present or future technology) are reserved to Guy Carpenter.

8. Disclaimer and Limitation of Liability

You agree that your use of the Service is at your sole risk and acknowledge that the Service and anything contained therein, including, but not limited to, content, services, goods or advertisements (the “Items”) are provided “AS IS” and that Guy Carpenter makes no warranty of any kind, express or implied, as to the Items, including, but not limited to, merchantability, noninfringement, title or fitness for a particular purpose or use. Guy Carpenter does not warrant that the Service is compatible with your equipment or is free of errors or viruses, worms or “Trojan horses” and is not liable for any damage you may suffer as a result of such destructive features. You agree that Guy Carpenter, its Suppliers and its third-party agents shall have no responsibility or liability for: (i) any injury or damages, whether caused by the negligence of Guy Carpenter, its employees, subcontractors, agents, Suppliers or otherwise arising in connection with the Service; or (ii) any fault, inaccuracy, omission, delay or any other failure in the Service caused by your computer equipment or arising from your use of the Service on such equipment. The content of other Web sites, services, goods or advertisements that may be linked to the Service is not maintained or controlled by Guy Carpenter. Guy Carpenter is therefore not responsible for the availability, content or accuracy of other Web sites, services or goods that may be linked to, or advertised on, the Service. Guy Carpenter does not: (a) make any warranty, express or implied, with respect to the use of the links provided on, or to, the Service; (b) guarantee the accuracy, completeness, usefulness or adequacy of any other Web sites, services, goods or advertisements that may be linked to the Service; or (c) make any endorsement, express or implied, of any other Web sites, services, goods or advertisements that may be linked to the Service. Guy Carpenter is also not responsible for the reliability or continued availability of the telephone lines and equipment you use to access the Service. You understand that Guy Carpenter and/or third-party contributors to the Service may choose at any time to inhibit or prohibit their content from being accessed under the TERMS.

9. Limitation of Liability

UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, NEGLIGENCE, SHALL GUY CARPENTER, ITS SUPPLIERS OR ITS THIRD-PARTY AGENTS BE LIABLE TO YOU OR ANY THIRD PARTY FOR DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, SPECIAL, PUNITIVE OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES EVEN IF AN AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OF GUY CARPENTER HAS BEEN ADVISED SPECIFICALLY OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES, ARISING FROM USE OF OR INABILITY TO USE THE SERVICE OR ANY LINKS OR ITEMS ON THE SERVICE OR ANY PROVISION OF THE TERMS, SUCH AS, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, LOSS OF REVENUE OR ANTICIPATED PROFITS OR LOST BUSINESS. (Applicable law may not allow the limitation or exclusion of liability or incidental or consequential damages.)

10. Representations and Warranties

You represent, warrant and covenant that you: (i) have the power and authority to enter into this agreement; (ii) are at least eighteen (18) years old; (iii) shall not use any rights granted hereunder for any unlawful purpose; and (iv) shall use the Service only as set forth in these TERMS.

11. Indemnification

You agree, at your own expense, to indemnify, defend and hold harmless Guy Carpenter and its employees, representatives, Suppliers and agents, against any claim, suit, action or other proceeding, to the extent based on or arising in connection with your use of the Service, or any links on the Service, including, but not limited to: (i) your use or someone using your computer’s use of the Service; (ii) a violation of the TERMS by you or anyone using your computer; (iii) a claim that any use of the Service by you or someone using your computer infringes any IP Right (as herein defined) of any third party, or any right of personality or publicity, is libelous or defamatory, or otherwise results in injury or damage to any third party; (iv) any deletions, additions, insertions or alterations to, or any unauthorized use of, the Service by you or someone using your computer; or (v) any misrepresentation or breach of representation, warranty or covenant made by you contained herein. You agree to pay any and all costs, damages and expenses (including reasonable attorneys’ fees) and costs awarded against or incurred by or in connection with or arising from any such claim, suit, action or proceeding.

12. Termination

Either you or Guy Carpenter may terminate this agreement with or without cause at any time and effective immediately. You may terminate by discontinuing use of the Service and destroying all materials obtained from the Service. This agreement will terminate immediately without notice from Guy Carpenter if Guy Carpenter determines, in its sole discretion, that you have failed to comply with any provision of these TERMS. Upon termination by you or upon notice of termination by Guy Carpenter , you must promptly destroy all materials obtained from the Service and any copies thereof. Sections 2, 3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 11, 12, and 13 shall survive any termination of this agreement.

13. Governing Law

These TERMS shall be governed and construed in accordance with the laws of the United States of America and the State of New York, without giving effect to conflicts-of-law principles thereof. You agree to submit to the personal jurisdiction of the state and federal courts located in New York County with respect to any legal proceedings arising out of this agreement and waive any objection to the propriety or convenience of venue in such courts. If any provision of the TERMS is found by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid or unenforceable, such provision shall be enforced to the maximum extent permissible and the other provisions of the TERMS shall remain in full force and effect.

14. Access Outside the United States

If you choose to access the Service from outside the United States, you are responsible for compliance with foreign and local laws. Software from the Service may be subject to United States export controls that prohibit downloading, exportation or re-exportation: (i) into (or to a national or resident of) Cuba, Iraq, Libya, Iran, Syria, Sudan, or any other country to which the U.S. has embargoed goods; or (ii) to anyone on the U.S. Treasury Department’s Table of Deny Orders. By using the Service, you represent and warrant that you are not located in, controlled by or a national or resident of any such country or on any such list.

15. Miscellaneous

You acknowledge that Guy Carpenter has the right to change the content or technical specifications of any aspect of the Service at any time at Guy Carpenter’s sole discretion. You further accept that such changes may result in your being unable to access the Service.

16. Official Correspondence

Official Correspondence must be sent via postal mail to: Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC, 1166 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10036, Attn: Legal Department.